Image: US National Archives, Staten Island, 1973
Comments & Testimony
Policy Actions
Below is a collection of some of the many actions taken by SWIM and its partners, including letters, comments, and testimonies. Topics range from waterbody-specific long term control plans (LTCP) to citywide zoning rules.
Learn more about SWIM's platforms by exploring Our Mission.
Find more information and resources in Our Work and External Resources.
Don't see what you're looking for? Contact us.
​
2023
​
Public Testimony on the NYS Dept. of Environmental Conservation Water Quality Standards for Saline Waters:
​
SWIM Coalition Public Comments on Water Quality Standards, June 20, 2023
​
​
Public Testimony on the NYC Water Board's Proposed Amendments to the Water Rate Schedule:
​
SWIM Coalition Public Comments on NYC Water Board Proposed Rate Schedule, June 5, 2023
​
NRDC Public Comments on NYC Water Board Proposed Rate Schedule, June 2, 2023
​
​
​
2022
​
Public Testimony on the NYC Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) 2021 Unified Stormwater Rule:
​
SWIM Coalition Public Testimony on the NYC DEP 2021 Unified Stormwater Rule, January 10, 2022
​
2021
​
Public Testimony on NYC Council Joint Hearing on Green Infrastructure, Urban Flooding, and Combined Sewer Overflows:
​
SWIM Coalition Public Testimony for NYC Council Joint Hearing on Stormwater Resiliency, October 20, 2021
​
​
​
​
NY LCV Public Testimony for NYC Council Joint Hearing on Stormwater Resiliency, October 20, 2021
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Comment Letter on NYC DEP Contingency Plan for Meeting GI Plan Milestones:
​
Green Infrastructure Stakeholder Working Group Comment Letter to DEC and DEP, August 2021
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Public Comment Letter to NYC Department of Environmental Protection on the Draft 2020 Stormwater Management Program Annual Report:
​
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Testimony to NYC Water Board for Proposed Fiscal Year 2022 Water and Wastewater Rates:
​
​
​
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Comment Letters regarding the NYC Department of City Planning's Draft Comprehensive Waterfront Plan:
​
​
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Testimony in support of NYC Council Intro calling for the Establishment of a Citywide Shoreline Study:
SWIM and Riverkeeper Public Testimony for hearing on NYC Council Intro 1679-A, April 23, 2021
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Comment Letters Opposing New York State's Department of Environmental Conservation's Proposal to set Lax Water Quality Standards for New York City's Class I and SD Waters:
​
SWIM Coalition Comment Letter to NYS DEC on Proposed Amendments to 6 NYCRR 703.4, March 29, 2021
​
​
NYC H20 Comment Letter to NYS DEC on Proposed Amendments to 6 NYCRR 703.4, March 29, 2021
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Public Comment Letter on the Office of Long Term Planning & Sustainability's Proposed Rule on Priority Districts for NY Green Roof Tax Abatement Program:
​
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Testimony on NYC Construction Code revisions to regulate Impermeability of Lots:
​
SWIM Public Testimony for hearing on NYC Council Intro 962, Feb 8, 2021
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
2020
​
Public Comment Letters on NYC DCP Comprehensive Waterfront Planning Framework:
​
SWIM Coalition Public Comment Letter on Comprehensive Waterfront Planning Framework, Nov 30, 2020
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Comment Letters on NYC EDC Coney Island Creek Ferry Landing:
​
SWIM Coalition Public Comment Letter on Coney Island Creek Ferry Landing, August 20, 2020
​
​
​
​
​
NYC H20 Public Comment Letter on Coney Island Creek Ferry Landing, August 25, 2020
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Testimony and Comment Letters on NYC City Council Intro 1851:
SWIM Coalition Public Testimony for hearing on NYC City Council Intro 1851, August 17, 2020
​
Riverkeeper Public Testimony for hearing on NYC City Council Intro 1851, August 13, 2020
​
Bronx River Alliance Public Testimony for hearing on NYC City Council Intro 1851, August 14, 2020
​
Newtown Creek Alliance Public Testimony for hearing on NYC City Council Intro 1851, August 14, 2020
​
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Comment Letters on NYC DEP 2019 Annual Report on the City's Stormwater Management Plan for the Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System:
​
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Public Testimony on Proposed Fiscal Year 2021 Water and Wastewater Rates:
SWIM Public Testimony on Proposed FY2021 Water and Wastewater Charges, June 12, 2020
​
NRDC Public Testimony on Proposed FY2021 Water and Wastewater Charges, June 12, 2020
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Comment Letters on NYC Dept. of Environmental Protection's Citywide Open Waters CSO LTCP:
​
SWIM Comment Letter on DEP Proposed Citywide/Open Waters CSO LTCP, March 2, 2020
​
​
​
Gowanus Canal Conservancy Comment Letter on DEP Proposed Citywide/Open Water CSO LTCP, March 2, 2020
​
Bronx River Alliance Comment Letter on DEP Proposed Citywide/Open Water CSO LTCP, March 2, 2020
​
​
​
Citizen Linda Cohen Comment Letter on DEP Proposed Citywide/Open Water CSO LTCP, March 2, 2020
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
SWIM Comment Letter on EPA Proposal for No Action on CSO in Newtown Creek, February 25, 2020
​
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
SWIM/Riverkeeper Joint Testimony for Renewable Rikers Public Hearing, January 29, 2020
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Public Testimony and Comments on DEC's Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters:
​
​
​
Newtown Creek Alliance Public Comment Letter for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
Gowanus Canal Conservancy Public Comment Letter for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
​
North Shore Waterfront Conservancy of Staten Island Public Comment Letter for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
​
Citizen Linda Cohen Public Comment for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
​
Citizen Laura Hofmann Public Comment Email for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
​
NYC H20 Public Comment Letter for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
​
Citizen Jack Bolembach Public Comment for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
​
Citizen Tom McGlinchey Public Comment Email for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
​
Citizen Ira Gershenhorn Comment Letter for DEC Proposed Rollback of Protective Language for NYC Waters, January 8, 2020
​
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
2019
2019 Public Comment Letters on NYC DEP Retained Alternatives for Citywide Open Waters CSO LTCP:
​
SWIM Coalition Public Comment Letter to DEP on the Fall 2019 Retained Alternatives Summary for the Citywide CSO Long Term Control Plan December 2, 2019
​
​
Waterfront Alliance Public Comment Letter to DEP on the Fall 2019 Retained Alternatives Summary for the Citywide CSO Long Term Control Plan
​
Van Cortland Park Alliance Comment Letter to DEP on the Fall 2019 Retained Alternatives Summary for the Citywide CSO Long Term Control Plan December 2, 2019
​​​
North Shore Waterfront Conservancy of Staten Island Public Comment Letter to DEP on the Fall 2019 Retained Alternatives Summary for the Citywide CSO Long Term Control Plan December 2, 2019
​
NYC H20 Public Comment Letter to DEP on the Fall 2019 Retained Alternatives Summary for the Citywide/Open Waters CSO Long Term Control Plan December 2, 2019
​
Citizen Gregory O'Mullan Comment Letter to DEP to DEP on the Fall 2019 Retained Alternatives Summary for the Citywide CSO Long Term Control Plan December 2, 2019
​
Bronx Council for Environmental Quality Public Comment Letter to DEP on the Fall 2019 Retained Alternatives Summary for the Citywide CSO Long Term Control Plan December 2, 2019
​
Bronx Community Board 8 Comment Letter to DEP Open Waters LTCP: Tibbetts Brook Daylighting December 2, 2019
​
​​Citizen John Doyle Comment Letter Email to DEP on to DEP on the Fall 2019 Retained Alternatives Summary for the Citywide CSO Long Term Control Plan December 2, 2019
​
​Citizen Rob Buchanan Comment Letter Email to DEP on the Open Waters LTCP April 17, 2019
________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
SWIM Coalition Public Comment for DEP GI Grant Rule Change
________________________________________________________________________________________________
Waterfront Alliance Legislative Memorandum of Support - Intro 1620
________________________________________________________________________________________________
SWIM Coalition Public Engagement Recommendations for DEP Water Rate Study
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
SWIM Coalition Legislative Memorandum of Support - Intro 1618
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Public Comment Letters to NYC Water Board on Proposed Fiscal Year 2020 Water/Wastewater Charges:
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
​
Gowanus Canal Community Advisory Group Comment Letter on Gowanus Neighborhood Rezoning and Related Actions - Draft Scope of Work. April 23, 2019
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
Riverkeeper Testimony for New York City Council Committee on Governmental Operations hearing on proposed Local Law Int. 0982-2018. April 17, 2019
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
SWIM Coalition Public Testimony for NYC City Council Public Hearing on Green Roof Laws. January 28, 2019
​
​
________________________________________________________________________________________________
2018
SWIM Coalition Public Comment Letter to DEC on New York City DEP’s deadline extension request for the Citywide Combined Sewer Overflow Long Term Control Plan. November 8, 2018
​
Waterfront Alliance Public Comment Letter to DEC on New York City DEP’s deadline extension request for the Citywide Combined Sewer Overflow Long Term Control Plan. November 29, 2018
​
​
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
usace Storm barrier Study comments
SWIM Coalition Comment Letter to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for New York - New Jersey Harbor and Tributaries Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study September 24, 2018
​
​
​
Municipal Art Society Comment Letter to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for New York - New Jersey Harbor and Tributaries Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study September 26, 2018
​
Bronx River Alliance Comment Letter to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for New York - New Jersey Harbor and Tributaries Coastal Storm Risk Management Feasibility Study September 13, 2018
​
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
​
SWIM Coalition Comment Letter to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters August 6, 2018
​
Bronx River Alliance Comment Letter to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters August 6, 2018
​
Westchester County Comment Letter to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters August 6, 2018
​
North Shore Waterfront Conservancy of Staten Island Comment Letter to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters August 17, 2018
​
Citizen Linda Cohen Comment Letter Email to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters August 6, 2018
​
Citizen Meghan Waters Comment Letter Email to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters August 6, 2018
​
Citizen Tom McGlinchey Comment Letter Email to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters August 4, 2018
​
Citizen Jenny McCormack Comment Letter Email to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters August 2, 2018
​
Citizen Judith Weis Comment Letter Email to DEC for proposed 303 (d) delisting of impaired waters July 31, 2018
​
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
​
SWIM Comment Letter to DEP for Jamaica Bay Long Term Control Plan June 4, 2018
​
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
​
SWIM Testimony for DEC hearing on proposed changes to water quality standards for NYC waterways June 12, 2018
​
NYS Assembly Comment Letter for DEC on proposed changes to water quality standards for NYC waterways June 12, 2018
​
Alliance for the Great Lakes Public Comment for DEC on proposed changes to water quality standards for NYC waterways June 12, 2018
​
NYC H20 Testimony for DEC hearing on proposed changes to water quality standards for NYC waterways June 12, 2018
​
June 12, 2018
​
Gowanus Canal Conservancy Testimony for DEC hearing on proposed changes to water quality standards for NYC waterways June 12, 2018
​
June 12, 2018
​
June 12, 2018
​
​
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
​
May 31, 2018
​
May 31, 2018
​
SWIM Comment Letter to NYC Water Board's proposed fiscal year 2019 water and sewer rates May 29,1028
​
SWIM Comment Letter to NYCDEP on NYC Stormwater Management Program Plan for NYC Municipal Storm
Sewer System May 15, 2018
​
Queens College Comment to NYCDEP on NYC Stormwater Management Program Plan for NYC Municipal Storm
Sewer System May 15,2018
​
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
​
Intro 750 April 23, 2018
​
SWIM Testimony to NYC City Council Committee for Environmental Protection on threats to Jamaica Bay Intro 750
April 23, 2018
​
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Testimony to NYC City Council Committee for Environmental
Protection on sea level rise scenarios April 23, 2018
​
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
​
April 3, 2018
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
City Council Letter to Mayor de Blasio calling for fishable swimmable waterways in NYC February 27, 2018
​
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
​
SWIM Comment Letter to NYS DEC regarding Combined Sewer Overflow Consent Order February 9, 2018
​
NYC Council Member Costa Costantinides - Comment Letter to NYS DEC regarding Combined Sewer Overflow Consent Order February 9, 2018
​
Gowanus Canal Conservancy - Comment Letter to NYS DEC regarding Combined Sewer Overflow Consent Order
​
Guardians of Flushing Bay - Comment Letter to NYS DEC regarding Combined Sewer Overflow Consent Order
​
Newtown Creek Alliance - Comment Letter to NYS DEC regarding Combined Sewer Overflow Consent Order
​
NYC H2O - Comment Letter to NYS DEC regarding Combined Sewer Overflow Consent Order January 30, 2018
​
​
​
​
2017
SWIM - Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental Protection: Public hearing on the City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans. December 13, 2017.
​
Newtown Creek Alliance - Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental: Protection: Public hearing on the City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans. December 13, 2017.
​
Gowanus Canal Conservancy - Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental Protection: Public hearing on the City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans. December 13, 2017.
​
Guardians of Flushing Bay - Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental Protection: Public hearing on
the City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans. December 13, 2017.
​
NYC Empire Dragon Boat Team - Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental Protection: Public hearing on the City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans. December 13, 2017.
​
Waterfront Alliance -Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental Protection: Public hearing on the
City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans. December 13, 2017.
​
NRDC -Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental Protection: public hearing on the City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans.
​
Riverkeeper - Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental Protection: public hearing on the
City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans. December 13, 2017.
​
Save the Sound - Testimony before the NYC City Council for Environmental Protection: public hearing on the
City's Wastewater and Stormwater Infrastructure - Current Condition and Future Plans. December 13, 2017.
​
SWIM - Testimony before the NYC Council Committee for Environmental Protection: DEP budget and oversight public hearing. March 23, 2017. Additional testimony from NRDC.
​
​
2016
​
SWIM - Testimony before the NYC Council Committee for Environmental Protection: Public hearing on new legislation granting DEP the authority to enforce rules for reducing stormwater runoff on development and retrofit sites. Additional testimony from NRDC, Riverkeeper, and Gaia Institute.
​
SWIM/Newtown Creek Alliance - Comment Letter to NYC DEP regarding the Newtown Creek LTCP
SWIM - Comment Letter to the Army Corp of Engineers regarding the Atlantic Coast of New York, East Rockaway Inlet to Rockaway Inlet and Jamaica Bay: Hurricane Sandy General Reevaluation Report And Environmental Impact Statement
​
SWIM - Comment Letter to DEP regarding the Flushing Bay CSO LTCP
​
​
Queens College - Comment on the General LTCP
​
Guardians of Flushing Bay - Comment on the Flushing Bay LTCP
​
​
2015
​
Nicole Zehr - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Alley Creek CSO LTCP
Save the Sound - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Alley Creek CSO LTCP
SWIM - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Alley Creek CSO LTCP
SWIM - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Coney Island Creek CSO LTCP
Queens College - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Flushing Creek CSO LTCP
SWIM - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Flushing Creek CSO LTCP
SWIM - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Hutchinson River CSO LTCP
SWIM - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Westchester Creek CSO LTCP
Guardians of Flushing Bay - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Flushing Creek CSO LTCP
Empire Dragon Boat Team - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Flushing Creek CSO LTCP
Friends of Flushing Creek - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Flushing Creek CSO LTCP
​
SWIM / Riverkeeper - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Gowanus Canal CSO LTCP
NYCDEP - Response to SWIM / Riverkeeper on Gowanus Canal CSO LTCP
Nature Conservancy - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Bronx River CSO LTCP
SWIM - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Bronx River CSO LTCP
​
Bronx River Alliance - Comment Letter for NYCDEP Bronx River CSO LTCP
SWIM - Public Comment Letter to NYC Water Board on FY 16 Water and Wastewater Rates
Bronx Council for Environmental Quality (BCEQ) - Revised Draft MS4 Permit
City of New York - Revised Draft MS4 Permit
Friends of Brook Park - Revised Draft MS4 Permit
NRDC / Riverkeeper / NY/NJ Baykeeper - Revised MS4 Draft Permit
NYC Water Trail Association (NYCWTA) - Revised Draft MS4 Permit
Phillip Jonat - Revised Draft MS4 Permit
Lewis and Gould Architects - Revised Draft MS4 Permit
Hackensack Riverkeeper / NY/ NJ Baykeeper - Water Quality Standards Rulemaking
Riverkeeper / NRDC - Water Quality Standards Rulemaking
SWIM - Water Quality Standards Rulemaking
DEP - Water Quality Standards Rulemaking
Empire Dragon Boat Team - Water Quality Standards Rulemaking
Jamaica Bay Ecowatchers - Water Quality Standards Rulemaking
​
New York City Water Trail Association - Water Quality Standards Rulemaking - Brous
New York City Water Trail Association - Water Quality Standards Rulemaking - Buchanan
​
​
2014
Bronx Council for Environmental Quality (BCEQ) - Annual LTCP Meeting
Empire Dragon Boat Team - Flushing Creek LTCP
SWIM - Hutchinson River and General LTCP
SWIM - Open Industrial Uses Study
CAC NY-NJ HEP - Clear Water State Revolving Fund
SWIM - Revised Draft MS4 Permit
City of New York - Draft MS4 Permit
CAC NY-NJ HEP - Draft MS4 Permit
NRDC / Riverkeeper / NY/NJ Baykeeper - DrafT MS4 Permit
​
Empire Dragon Boat Team - Draft MS4 Permit
​
​
NYS Supreme Court - DEPvDEC Alley Creek LTCP
​
​
2013
​
SWIM - Green Infrastructure Initiatives
​
​
NRDC - On study of materials for Permeable Surfaces
​
​
2012
​
SWIM - Local Law 5 Requirements: Letter to the NYC Report & Advisory Board Review Commission
​
​
2011
​
SWIM - 2011 Modification of CSO Consent Order
​
​
​
​
2010
​
SWIM - Preliminary Comments on NYC Green Infrastructure Plan
DEP - Response to SWIM about Preliminary Comments on NYC Green Infrastructure Plan
SWIM - Draft recommendations to Vision 2020: The New York City Comprehensive Waterfront Plan
​
SWIM - Testimony before the NYC Council Committee on Environmental Protection about Stormwater Tolerant Planting and Control of Invasive Species
​
SWIM - Comments to NYC Departments of Housing Preservation and Development and Parks and Recreation on the proposed “Greenthumb Gardens” rules, stating that “we know community gardens as places of experimentation and creativity, incubators of stewardship and civic engagement, and an important part of Green Infrastructure.”
​
SWIM - LTCP Public Participation
SWIM - Testimony before the NYC Water Board on the NYC Department of Environmental Protection’s proposed water rates for FY 2010-2011
SWIM Members - Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL)
​
EPA - Response to DEP about CWA efforts in the NY-NJ Harbor
​
EPA - Response to SWIM’s March 4th, 2010 Letter
​
​
2009
​
SWIM - NYC Waterbody Advisory Program
​
SWIM Members - Testimony before Committee on Environmental Protection of the Council of the City of New York on “The Implementation of PlaNYC’s Sustainable Stormwater Management Plan”
SWIM - Letter to Honorable Michael R. Bloomberg, Mayor of the City of New York, re: draft rules for implementing green roof tax abatement
SWIM - Testimony before NYC Department of Buildings on Draft Green Roof Tax Abatement Rules
​
​
​
2008
​
SWIM - Green Roof Tax Abatement
​
Riverkeeper - Testimony before the Council of the City of New York, “Should the Ridgewood Reservoir Be Preserved as a Wetland?”
​
​
Sustainable South Bronx - Street Trees Planting and Yard Text Amendments
​
Sustainable South Bronx - Proposed Zoning Text Amendments Concerning Streets and Yards
​
​
2007
​
​
​
SWIM Members - Testimony before the Council of the City of New York on “Rising Waters: What Can the DEP Do About Flooding?”
​
CSO CAC - Points for Consideration in Developing Fall 2007 CSO Stakeholder Meeting Agenda
​
CSO CAC - Response to DEP Presentations
​
SWIM - Letter to NYS Department of Environmental Conservation Commissioner Pete Grannis
​
​
2006
​
​
​